My Thoughts

Why Your Company's Dress Code is Outdated: A Wake-Up Call from the Trenches

Yesterday, I watched a brilliant software engineer get sent home from our Sydney office because his sneakers weren't "appropriate business attire." The same bloke who'd just solved a problem that saved the company $50K. And I thought: we've completely lost the plot.

After seventeen years in workplace consulting—from mining sites in WA to corporate towers in Melbourne—I've seen dress codes destroy more good talent than any other single policy. Yet most companies cling to them like they're the bloody Ten Commandments.

Here's what nobody wants to admit: your dress code isn't about professionalism. It's about control. And it's costing you the best people.

The Great Shoe Scandal of 2023

Let me tell you about Sarah. Brilliant marketing manager, moved from Brisbane to take a role with a Fortune 500 company. First day, HR pulls her aside. Her perfectly respectable flats weren't "executive standard." They needed heels. Minimum two inches.

Sarah lasted three weeks.

Not because she couldn't do the job—she was already turning around their digital campaigns. But because every morning became a battle between comfort and compliance. Between being able to think clearly and wobbling around like a newborn giraffe.

The kicker? She's now freelancing, earning double what they paid her, working with their competitors. Wearing whatever shoes she damn well pleases.

That's the hidden cost of outdated dress codes. You don't just lose good people—you actively create your own competition.

What Actually Matters (Spoiler: It's Not Your Tie)

I've worked with over 200 companies across Australia. Want to know what separates the high-performers from the also-rans? It's never been about pressed shirts or polished shoes.

It's about psychological safety. Communication clarity. Whether people feel valued for their contributions rather than their costume choices.

The most successful teams I've worked with? Half of them showed up in trackies. The CEO of one tech startup in Adelaide rocks up in board shorts most days. Revenue: $15 million and climbing.

Meanwhile, I've consulted for companies where everyone looks like they stepped out of a magazine spread. Beautiful suits, perfect hair, immaculate makeup. And the most toxic, unproductive workplace culture you've ever seen.

Correlation doesn't equal causation, but patterns don't lie.

The Real Professional Standards

Here's what actually matters in modern business:

Cleanliness. Nobody wants to work with someone who smells like last week's leftover pizza. Basic hygiene isn't negotiable.

Context awareness. Meeting with conservative clients? Dress accordingly. Internal team meeting? Wear what makes you productive.

Respect for safety. Steel-cap boots on construction sites. Closed-toe shoes in labs. Safety gear where required. Non-negotiable.

Cultural sensitivity. Understanding when certain occasions call for certain attire. Not rocket science.

Everything else? It's just corporate theatre.

The Productivity Paradox

I once ran time management training for a law firm with a strict formal dress code. Fascinating results. Productivity dropped 23% on hot days because people were more focused on not sweating through their suits than on actual work.

The women consistently reported lower comfort levels, higher stress, and more frequent breaks to adjust clothing. The men complained about restricted movement and discomfort during long meetings.

Six months later, they trialled "Comfort Fridays." Productivity jumped. Client satisfaction scores improved. Stress-related sick days dropped.

But did they change their policy permanently? Of course not. Because admitting dress codes are counterproductive would mean admitting they've been wrong for decades.

The Generation Gap Reality Check

Here's the uncomfortable truth: Gen Z and younger millennials simply won't tolerate arbitrary dress codes. They've got options, and they know it.

I've watched companies hemorrhage talent because they refused to modernise their appearance policies. Meanwhile, their competitors are snapping up the same talent with more flexible approaches.

One manufacturing company in Newcastle couldn't understand why they couldn't attract young engineers. Their dress code required business shirts and dress shoes on the factory floor. Competitors allowed polo shirts and safety sneakers.

Guess where the talent went?

The excuse is always the same: "But what will clients think?" Here's what clients actually think about: results, reliability, and value. If your dress code is interfering with any of those, you're doing it wrong.

The Client Excuse Myth

Speaking of clients—this is where companies get really defensive about dress codes. "Our clients expect a certain standard," they insist.

Rubbish. I've been in client meetings in everything from suits to safety vests, depending on the context. Professional clients care about competence, not costume design.

The most successful client relationship I ever built? Started in a mining office where everyone wore high-vis and steel caps. The client never once mentioned our appearance because we were too busy solving their $2 million logistics problem.

Your clients aren't judging your clothes. They're judging your results.

The Discrimination Nobody Talks About

Dress codes disproportionately impact certain groups, and we all know it. Women face impossible standards—professional but not too sexy, fashionable but not distracting, expensive but not showing off.

People from different cultural backgrounds struggle with codes that assume Western business norms. Those with physical disabilities find many "professional" clothing options uncomfortable or impractical.

And let's talk about the economic discrimination. "Professional" clothing is expensive. Requiring specific brands or styles effectively creates a financial barrier to employment.

I've seen talented people pass up job opportunities because they couldn't afford the wardrobe requirements. That's not maintaining standards—that's excluding potential based on wallet size.

The Productivity Revolution

The companies getting this right are seeing remarkable results. Effective communication training becomes more impactful when people are comfortable and confident in their own skin—literally.

One Adelaide-based consultancy I worked with saw a 31% improvement in creative output after relaxing their dress code. Teams collaborated more freely, took more risks, and felt more authentic in their interactions.

The magic wasn't in the clothes—it was in removing the artificial barrier between people's professional and personal identities.

What Smart Companies Do Instead

Progressive organisations are replacing dress codes with outcome codes. Instead of dictating appearance, they focus on:

Client appropriateness
Safety requirements
Team alignment
Cultural sensitivity

They trust their people to dress appropriately for context. Revolutionary concept, I know.

Some have "dress for your day" policies. Client presentation? Dress up. Internal work session? Dress for productivity. Simple.

Others provide clothing allowances rather than strict requirements. Want designer suits? Great, here's a budget. Prefer comfortable alternatives? Also great, here's the same budget.

The Bottom Line

Your dress code is sending a message about your company values. Is it the message you want to send?

If you're saying "we value conformity over creativity," "appearance over ability," or "control over trust," then congratulations—your current dress code is working perfectly.

But if you want to attract top talent, improve productivity, and build a culture where people actually want to work, it's time for a serious rethink.

The future belongs to companies that judge people on what they produce, not what they wear to produce it.

And honestly? It's about bloody time.

Further Reading: